Dust Collector VFD selection and speed questions

09, Sep. 2024

 

Dust Collector VFD selection and speed questions



Question #1 - Do any of you have direct experience with specific VFDs running a 3-phase dust collector? I am currently doing a selection process and the results are all over the board. I do know that the VFDs which are 3-phase input will need to be de-rated (i.e. doubled in amperage/size) if you are using single phase source. However, the VFDs that are "single phase input to 3 phase output" are configured to support full amperage/capacity without the need to double the VFD size. My understanding is that it mostly has to do with input diode capability (but I could be wrong). When searching for VFD choices, I see a variety of results. The following are all specifically 5HP "single phase input" models.

First are the higher price results.

Eaton 5HP ($634) - this is the largest in physical size. It actually matches the physical size of the bigger ATO 7.5HP VFD.
https://www.grainger.com/product/EAT...ve-240V-20RA66

Invertek 5HP IP 20 ($610)
https://www.wolfautomation.com/ac-dr...-240v-1-phase/

Invertek 5HP IP66 ($850) - Interestingly, this model is specifically listed as being "dust tight" and water resistant.
https://www.wolfautomation.com/vfd-5...se-input-3-ph/



In the middle level, I found the ATO 5HP Single Phase to Three Phase VFD ($294)
https://www.ato.com/5hp-vfd



Both the Invertek and ATO have very large and detailed documentation online IN ENGLISH!!. ATO manual is 169 pages. Invertek models have a general manual and an advanced technical manual at about 50 pages each. I could not find any documentation for Eaton. Their web pages seem to hint that they want contractors to sign up for training programs on these types of products.

The ATO has a built-in potentiometer knob on the front face. The Eaton and Invertek will need to have an external potentiometer wired in and configured for speed control.


Then there is a multitude of cheaper Chinese import models available in the $150-200 price range. These are actually smaller in physical size than the ATO/Invertek. These are brands such as Mollom, Huanyang, HKS, Lapond, Vevor, XCFDP, etc., etc. When doing a detailed look on these cheaper ones, a lot of them appear to be half-baked designs with lacking functionality and potential unforeseen implementation issues. They are also all very small in physical size compared to the ATO/Invertek (this tells me there's not much inside or uses cheap components/capacitors, etc.). Interestingly, all these cheaper items have a good number of reviews on Amazon with a 4+ star average rating There's almost no reviews on ATO VFDs on Amazon (maybe because most people are cheap).

I am leaning towards ATO because of documentation, support and perceived quality level. I know that Chris Parks has recommended Huanyang and Powtran. Huanyang does not have a working front panel potentiometer and I cannot find a good source for Powtran.

Does anyone here have direct practical experience with these items that can provide a recommendation?




Question #2 - What is the slowest speed to safely run this motor on the dust collector. It's going to be a 5HP Baldor 3 phase motor. I have seen some recommendations that speed should not ever be below 80% of specification, but I think that mostly has to do with single phase capacitor-start motors. I know that there is going to be a minimum speed required to get the FPM required to pull dust through the ducts. However, I want to drop the speed to reduce noise as much as possible (with the understanding that I'll have to crank it back up if I run multiple tools.

I am in planning project mode for a new ClearVue 5HP 3 phase dust collector. It will be run from a VFD. However, I have not found a whole lot of documented experience with dust collectors and VFD (only general information). So, I have a couple questions.Question #1 - Do any of you have direct experience with specific VFDs running a 3-phase dust collector? I am currently doing a selection process and the results are all over the board. I do know that the VFDs which are 3-phase input will need to be de-rated (i.e. doubled in amperage/size) if you are using single phase source. However, the VFDs that are "single phase input to 3 phase output" are configured to support full amperage/capacity without the need to double the VFD size. My understanding is that it mostly has to do with input diode capability (but I could be wrong). When searching for VFD choices, I see a variety of results. The following are all specifically 5HP "single phase input" models.First are the higher price results.Eaton 5HP ($634) - this is the largest in physical size. It actually matches the physical size of the bigger ATO 7.5HP VFD.Invertek 5HP IP 20 ($610)Invertek 5HP IP66 ($850) - Interestingly, this model is specifically listed as being "dust tight" and water resistant.In the middle level, I found the ATO 5HP Single Phase to Three Phase VFD ($294)Both the Invertek and ATO have very large and detailed documentation online IN ENGLISH!!. ATO manual is 169 pages. Invertek models have a general manual and an advanced technical manual at about 50 pages each. I could not find any documentation for Eaton. Their web pages seem to hint that they want contractors to sign up for training programs on these types of products.The ATO has a built-in potentiometer knob on the front face. The Eaton and Invertek will need to have an external potentiometer wired in and configured for speed control.Then there is a multitude of cheaper Chinese import models available in the $150-200 price range. These are actually smaller in physical size than the ATO/Invertek. These are brands such as Mollom, Huanyang, HKS, Lapond, Vevor, XCFDP, etc., etc. When doing a detailed look on these cheaper ones, a lot of them appear to be half-baked designs with lacking functionality and potential unforeseen implementation issues. They are also all very small in physical size compared to the ATO/Invertek (this tells me there's not much inside or uses cheap components/capacitors, etc.). Interestingly, all these cheaper items have a good number of reviews on Amazon with a 4+ star average rating There's almost no reviews on ATO VFDs on Amazon (maybe because most people are cheap).I am leaning towards ATO because of documentation, support and perceived quality level. I know that Chris Parks has recommended Huanyang and Powtran. Huanyang does not have a working front panel potentiometer and I cannot find a good source for Powtran.Does anyone here have direct practical experience with these items that can provide a recommendation?Question #2 - What is the slowest speed to safely run this motor on the dust collector. It's going to be a 5HP Baldor 3 phase motor. I have seen some recommendations that speed should not ever be below 80% of specification, but I think that mostly has to do with single phase capacitor-start motors. I know that there is going to be a minimum speed required to get the FPM required to pull dust through the ducts. However, I want to drop the speed to reduce noise as much as possible (with the understanding that I'll have to crank it back up if I run multiple tools.

ZCL supply professional and honest service.

Choosing and Installing iVac Automated Dust Collection ...

An iVac Automated Dust Collection System takes the hassle out of operating your dust collector.

iVac has become well-known for making it easy to automate the dust collection system for any shop, big or small. Here at Infinity we have done our best to make choosing the right iVac package for your shop easy and worry-free. Let me show you how to go about connecting your dust collector to an iVac system and exactly what you'll need. In short, it all depends on the size of your dust collector's motor.

We've made it easy for you to select the right iVac system using the flowchart below.

An iVac Automated Dust Collection System takes the hassle out of operating your dust collector.

If your dust collector is relatively small and is rated at 8 amps or fewer (roughly 1 hp for 115v and 2hp for 230v) you can get by with just an iVac Pro Switch for a truly plug-and-play system. However, if your dust collector is rated at 9 amps or more you will need an iVac Contactor (115-107).

You can find the amperage rating for your dust collector by checking the label on the motor.

The iVac Contactor Dust Collector Controller (115-107) is a relay that is wired between your dust collector and the iVac Pro Switch. It insulates the switch from the higher amperage draw of a larger dust collector that might damage it if it were connected directly to your dust collector. The great part is, the Contactor only requires a 115V Pro Switch (115-102S) no matter what type of dust collector you have.

The iVac Contactor and the 115v iVac Pro Switch work together for any dust collector up to 10hp.

The beauty of the Contactor is that it makes your iVac system truly universal. It doesn't matter if your dust collector is 115v, 230v, or even 600 volts/3-phase, the Contactor will allow you to wire it right up. This is especially important if you have a small dust collector now and want to upgrade to a larger one in the future. You won't have to worry about your new dust collector being compatible with your iVac system.

NOTE: Before wiring up the contactor, be sure to consult with a licensed electrician and your local electrical codes first. And if you're not comfortable connecting the wiring yourself, by all means talk to an licensed electrician. The instructions and photos shown here are for illustrative purposes only and may not be representative of your local electrical codes. These are straightforward systems to wire and can be installed in short order. iVac includes a clear set of instructions that explain the basics of wiring your dust collector for use with the Contactor.

Infinity Cutting Tools is not responsible and cannot be held liable for any damages or injury that may occur from improper wiring.

Once you have power coming into the Contactor, connecting everything else in the iVac system is easy.

Wiring up the power cord for the iVac Contactor is as simple as connecting the ground wire and the hot and neutral leads which already have female termincal connectors installed.

The first step is to hook up the power cord that plugs into your 115V Pro Switch. This cord comes with the Contactor and already has all the connectors installed on the wires. Attach the ground (green) wire to the ground post on the Contactor box, and plug the hot wire (Black) and neutral wire (white) onto the posts on the relay.

Are you interested in learning more about Dust Proof Motor? Contact us today to secure an expert consultation!

The second step is to connect the A/C power source coming from the wall into the Contactor. For 115v and 230v collectors, this process is also pretty straightforward.

Connecting AC power from the wall to the contactor.

For a 115v dust collector (above, left) the hot and neutral wires from the A/C power source are connected to the L1 and L2 terminals. These two wires will bring power into the Contactor. You have a hot wire (black), a neutral wire (white), and a ground wire (green). Attach the ground wire to the ground post in the box. Attach the hot and neutral wires to the L1 and L2 terminals. It doesn't matter which wire goes to which terminal.

For a 230v dust collector (above, right) both hot wires coming from the power source are connected to the L1 and L2 terminals. These two wires will bring power into the Contactor. You'll have 2 hot wires (they could be red, black, or one of each) and a ground (green) wire. Attach the ground wire to the ground post in the box. Attach the 2 hot wires to the L1 and L2 terminals.

Connecting a dust collector is as simple as connecting the hot and neutral wires from the dust collector to the T1 and T2 terminals.

The third step is to attach the wires from your dust collector to the Contactor. For 115V (above, left), again you will have hot, neutral, and ground wires. ground goes to the ground post and the hot and neutral wires go to the T1 and T2 terminals. Simply match the wire colors from the L1 and L2 terminals. In other words, if the hot (black) wire from the wall is attached to L1 terminal make sure the hot (black) wire from the dust collector is attached to the T1 terminal.

For 230V, the process is exactly the same (above, right). Match wire to wire from L1 and L2 to T1 and T2 and you're set.

I'm not going to go into the details of wiring your system for 3-phase power, but the Contactor will work just fine if you have 3 Phase in your shop and need it for your dust collector. The T3 and L3 terminals are used for hooking up 3-phase machines.

The iVac Pro Tool Plus (115-111) simply clamps over your woodworking machine's power cord, senses current when you turn on the machine, which in turn powers on your dust collector.

The rest of the iVac system is very easy to install. The iVac Pro Tool Plus simply clamps onto the power cord of your machine, like a table saw, and then plugs into a 110V outlet. Similarly, the iVac Pro Blast Gate replaces your manual 4" blast gate and plugs into its own 110V outlet.

The iVac Pro Blast Gate (115-108) replaces a manual 4" blast gate and automatically opens and closes when you start your machine.

The Pro Tool Plus (115-111), Pro Blast Gate (115-108), and Pro Switches have a series of small DIP switches inside that allow you to program the system so everything works together and the correct blast gate opens when you turn on your machine. iVac also has very clear instructions for programming your system.

Programming the iVac System is as simple as following the included instructions and flipping the little switches inside on or off.

Each iVac Pro System can have up to 8 tools and 8 blast gates all connected to one dust collector. If you have a large shop with more than one dust collector you can have as many as 4 systems installed. This means up to 32 machines can be controlled by an iVac system without any issues.

Want more information on Slip Ring Motor for Hoist? Feel free to contact us.